The High Court of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) has reserved judgement in a suit seeking to compel the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) to provide access to materials used in conducting its July 2024 National Officers Elections.

The case, filed by presidential candidate Tobenna Erojikwe, challenges the Electoral Committee’s refusal to release election materials as mandated by the NBA Constitution.

The suit, numbered FCT/HC/4393/2024: Mr. Tobenna Erojikwe v Incorporated Trustees of the NBA; Mr. Oluseun Abimbola SAN; and Electionbuddy Inc, was heard on 12th September 2024 by Justice C. O. Agashiezi. The proceedings included consideration of three preliminary objections filed by the defendants.

According to an update released by Erojikwe dated 15th October 2024, NBA’s objection centres on his “alleged failure to exhaust the internal remedies provided by the Constitution,” while the other defendants raised issues regarding “alleged non-compliance with the legal requirements for serving the 3rd Defendant outside Nigeria.”

The legal action follows what Erojikwe describes as systematic non-compliance with constitutional provisions in the aftermath of the July 2024 NBA National Officers Elections. The controversy began when the Electoral Committee of the Nigerian Bar Association (ECNBA) allegedly refused to comply with constitutional requirements and prevented third-party access to electoral materials.

According to Erojikwe, “The ECNBA refused to comply with the Constitution, it also directed Electionbuddy Inc., whose platform was used to conduct the Election, to decline releasing the electoral materials to me.”

The National Officers’ Election Appeal Committee (NOEAC) members were also accused of bias, as Erojikwe provided evidence of alleged partisanship, particularly highlighting the actions of the Committee’s Chairman, Mr. Usman Sule, SAN, who had publicly “issued a statement commending and congratulating the leadership of NBA ‘for being steadfast for the emergence of the people’s President’.” The Chairman characterised the elections as “historic”, “epochal” and “the freest and fairest NBA General Election”.

In response to this display of alleged bias, Erojikwe requested the NOEAC members’ recusal, saying: “Having publicly expressed such partisan opinion over the conduct of the Elections, I wrote to the Appeal Committee and copied the immediate past President of the NBA, asking that the Chairman and members of the Appeal Committee recuse themselves and that a new and independent committee be set up to determine my petition.” According to Erojikwe, “neither the immediate past President of the NBA nor the Appeal Committee reacted to my letter.”

According to the update, Erojikwe subsequently discovered through court proceedings that the Appeal Committee had reached a decision without his knowledge. His words: “It was in a Further and Better Affidavit filed in that suit on 10th September, 2024, by Mr. Abdul Mohammed, SAN, on behalf of the NBA, that I first saw what was called the ‘Report of the Nigerian Bar Association National Officers Election Appeal Committee’ dated 26th August, 2024.”

At the core of Erojikwe’s petition are specific provisions of the NBA Constitution’s Second Schedule, Part II, Paragraph 8, which mandates the ECNBA to “establish a system that allows interested parties to access, in a timely manner, all critical information, documents, and databases used in an Elections process.” The Constitution further requires the ECNBA to “make freely available and in a timely manner the information on which each decision was based.”

Speaking on the allegation that the Appeal Committee’s handling of the petition has raised significant procedural concerns, Erojikwe wrote: “The Committee at the only sitting it had refused to hear evidence but rather stated that it was ‘merely a fact-finding Committee’. It proceeded to conduct its activities clandestinely, leading up to the secret Report that was sent to the President of the NBA.”

There are indications that the case has potential implications on electoral transparency and institutional accountability within Nigeria’s premier legal association, as the outcome may establish important precedents for handling electoral disputes within the NBA.

The full text of Erojikwe’s update is below.

To join our CITY LAWYER Channel on WhatsApp, click here

To join our Telegram platform, click here 

COPYRIGHT 2022 CITY LAWYER. Please send emails to citylawyermag@gmail.com. Join us on Facebook at https://web.facebook.com/City-Lawyer-Magazine-434937936684320 and on “X” (TWITTER) at https://twitter.com/CityLawyerMag. To ADVERTISE in CITY LAWYER or for Special Features, please email citylawyermag@gmail.com or call 08138380083.

All materials available on this Website are protected by copyright, trade mark and other proprietary and intellectual property laws. You may not use any of our intellectual property rights without our express written consent or attribution to www.citylawyermag.com. However, you are permitted to print or save to your individual PC, tablet or storage extracts from this Website for your own personal non-commercial use.